Read the following message.
Dear Mr. Meyer,
I am writing about the new driving restrictions your government department is suggesting for new drivers in the province. I definitely agree that certain restrictions are necessary to ensure road safety. However, I disagree with one major point.
Your department is proposing a “single passenger” restriction that allows a novice driver to have one passenger, unless the passengers are immediate family members. Your logic is simply that novice drivers are usually teenagers, and a car full of teenagers is distracting to the driver. You state that this rule has done much to reduce the incidence of crashes in other provinces.
There is simply no conclusive evidence to support this claim. In fact, there’s a major reason why the “one-passenger” rule might actually lead to more accidents on the road. Take for example a situation that happened last Saturday. My 16-year-old son, John, who recently got his novice driver’s license, needed to work on a school project with five of his classmates. They were making a short film for their history class, which required them to drive around the city visiting various museums. John has use of my van, which seats six people. Under the current law, he can drive his friends. He is a safe driver and no accidents happened. Under the proposed restriction, John would be legally allowed to drive only one passenger. His friends, who are also new drivers, would then have to take two other vehicles. Therefore, the “one-passenger” rule would actually triple the possibility of a crash by requiring the use of three cars, when only one was needed! Where’s the safety in that?
Because most novice drivers are teenagers, the proposal for the “one-passenger” rule will lead to more inexperienced teenage drivers being on the road at one time. Where two or three teenagers are following each other in separate cars, they may act foolishly by driving too fast or passing dangerously. I recognize the good intention behind your proposal, but I wonder if it will actually be effective.
Sincerely,
James Brandt
Using the drop-down menu ( ), choose the best option according to the information given in the message.